Atlas of Hillforts of Britain and Ireland

SC1201 Bute, Dunagoil, Buteshire

Satellite Imagery

Satellite Imagery

HER:  The West of Scotland Archaeology Service 4873 (None)

NMR:  NS 05 SE 4 (40291)

SM:  409

NGR:  NS 0847 5312

X:  208479  Y:  653127  (OSGB36)

Summary

The fort at Dunagoil occupies a craggy ridge on the coast S of Dunagoil Bay. The ridge is aligned ESE and WNW, dropping precipitously on the NNE and WNW, so much so that, the only defensive work along the cliff-edge is a short section of masonry with its outer face still 0.7m high blocking a gully leading up to the crest. Elsewhere the defences comprise a substantial wall some 3.6m thick which displays massive vitrifaction of its core the length of the SSW side. A run of the outer face is visible at the northern end of this side, but nothing can be seen of the inner face. There is also an entrance midway along this side, and another in the ESE end, where the wall measures 3.3m in thickness and cuts sharply back over the crest of the ridge to return a short distance along the cliff-edge on the NNE. The interior, which measures about 85m in length from ESE to WNW by up to 20m transversely (0.15ha), is featureless, and nothing can now be seen of the cross-wall noted on an estate plan of 1780 (Bute Archive). Excavations were carried out in 1914 and 1915, and again in 1919, though the results have been reported in only the most sketchy outline (Mann 1915; 1925; Marshall 1915). Nevertheless, several details indicate that the history of occupation on the hilltop included more than the construction and destruction of the fort. John Marshall, digging a trench into the masonry at the top of the gully on the NNE found chunks of vitrified stone reused in its fabric, from which he concluded that it was constructed after the main wall was destroyed (Marshall 1915, 45-6). This may have influenced Ludovic Mann's assertion that the fort had been extended eastwards at some point in its history, claiming that the new wall overlay midden from an earlier occupation, though whether this is an allusion to Marshall's trench on the E or an observation of his own of the main wall, as he implies, towards the ESE end of the fort is unclear (Mann 1925, 60). Nevertheless, the various trenches provided one of the richest assemblages of artefacts found in any fort in western Scotland, with a wide range of materials and evidence of metalworking (Mann 1915; 1925).

Status

Citizen Science:  

Reliability of Data:  Confirmed

Reliability of Interpretation:  Confirmed

Location

X:  -562380  Y:  7505566  (EPSG: 3857)

Longitude:  -5.05194322658526  Latitude:  55.733607124229906  (EPSG:4326)

Country:  Scotland

Current County or Unitary Authority:  Argyll & Bute

Historic County:  Buteshire

Current Parish/Community/Council/Townland:  Kingath

Monument Condition

None

Condition:
Extant  
Cropmark  
Likely Destroyed  

Land Use

None

Current Use:
Woodland  
Commercial Forestry Plantation  
Parkland  
Pasture (Grazing)  
Arable  
Scrub/Bracken  
Bare Outcrop  
Heather/Moorland  
Heath  
Built-up  
Coastal Grassland  
Other  

Landscape

Hillfort Type

None

Type:
Contour Fort  
Partial Contour Fort  
Promontory Fort  
Hillslope Fort  
Level Terrain Fort  
Marsh Fort  
Multiple Enclosure Fort  

Topographic Position

Position:
Hilltop  
Coastal Promontory  
Inland Promontory  
Valley Bottom  
Knoll/Hillock/Outcrop  
Ridge  
Cliff/Plateau-edge/Scarp  
Hillslope  
Lowland  
Spur  

Dominant Topographic Feature:  None

Aspect:
North  
Northeast  
East  
Southeast  
South  
Southwest  
West  
Northwest  
Level  

Altitude:  35.0m

Boundary

N/A


Dating Evidence

Wide range of finds, including ring-headed pins, a finger ring, a brooch, glass bangle fragments, spindle whorls, bone needles and pins, stone cups, crucibles and metalworking debris spanning an unknown period of occupation.

Reliability:  C - Low

Principal Activity:
Pre 1200BC  
1200BC - 800BC  
800BC - 400BC  
400BC - AD50  
AD50 - AD400  
AD400 - AD 800  
Post AD800  
Unknown  

Other Activity:
Pre Hillfort:   None
Post Hillfort:   None

Evidence:
Artefactual:   None

Investigation History

First surveyed on an estate map of 1780, the fort was depicted in 1863 on the 1st edition OS 25-inch map (Argyll and Bute 1869, sheet 227.2), and noted in 1880 (Ross 1880, 75-7). It was subsequently described in the 1890s in some detail by the Rev J K Hewison (1893, 289-92), and excavations were carried out by John Marshall and Ludovic Mann in 1914, 1915 and 1919 (Mann 1915; 1925; Marshall 1915). A description was drawn up in 1943 as part of the RCAHMS Emergency Surveys, and copies of photographs taken in 1958 by Helen Nisbet as part of her research into vitrified forts are held in RCAHMS (see Nisbet 1975). The fort seems to have been visited by Kenneth Steer about 1975, and the following year, 1976, by the OS. Two seasons of survey work were carried out in 1994-5 (Harding, Ralston and Burgess 1995; Harding 1997, 121; 2004a, 141-4; 2004b), suggesting that there was also a much larger fortification here taking in the adjacent ridge of outcrop to the NE, an interpretation that is not shared by RCAHMS investigators, who in 2009-10, in the course of a new survey, suggested that the evidence for this outer enclosure related to a much later agricultural landscape (Geddes and Hale 2010, 22-5). The fort was Scheduled in 1953, and re-Scheduled in 1993

Investigations:
Earthwork Survey (1780):   Estate plan (Bute archive, Mount Stuart)
1st Identified Map Depiction (1863):   Annotated Fort on the 1st edition OS 25-inch map (Argyll and Bute 1869, sheet 227.2)
Other (1880):   Noted (Ross 1880, 75-7)
Other (1893):   Description by James King Hewison (1893, 289-92)
Excavation (1914):   and 1915 (Mann 1915; Marshall 1915)
Excavation (1919):   Ludovic Mann (1925)
Other (1943):   Description (RCAHMS Emergency Surveys)
Other (1953):   Scheduled
Other (1958):   Visited by Helen Nisbet (Nisbet 1975; Photographs held by RCAHMS)
Other (1975):   Visited by Kenneth Steer
Other (1993):   Re-Scheduled
Earthwork Survey (1995):   In the field 1994 & 1995 (Harding, Ralston and Burgess 1995; Harding 1997, 121; 2004a, 141-4; 2004b)
Other (2009):   Description (RCAHMS)
Earthwork Survey (2010):   Plan and description (Geddes and Hale 2010, 22-5; RCAHMS DC49423 & SC1231881)

Interior Features

Featureless

Water Source

None

Source:
None  
Spring  
Stream  
Pool  
Flush  
Well  
Other  

Surface

None

Interior Features (Surface):
No Known Features  
Round Stone Structures  
Rectangular Stone Structures  
Curvilinear Platforms  
Other Roundhouse Evidence  
Pits  
Quarry Hollows  
Other  

Excavation

Early excavation by Ludovic Mann.

Interior Features (Excavation):
No Known Excavation  
Pits  
Postholes  
Roundhouses  
Rectangular Structures  
Roads/Tracks  
Quarry Hollows  
Other  
Nothing Found  

Geophysics

None

Interior Features (Geophysics):
No Known Geophysics  
Pits  
Roundhouses  
Rectangular Structures  
Roads/Tracks  
Quarry Hollows  
Other  
Nothing Found  

Finds

Wide range of finds, including ring-headed pins, a finger ring, a brooch, glass bangle fragments, spindle whorls, bone needles and pins, stone cups, crucibles and metalworking debris (Mann 1915; 1925).

Interior (Finds):
No Known Finds  
Pottery  
Metal  
Metalworking  
Human Bones  
Animal Bones  
Lithics  
Environmental  
Other  

Aerial

NO APPARENT FEATURES

Interior Features (Aerial):
APs Not Checked  
None  
Roundhouses  
Rectangular Structures  
Pits  
Postholes  
Roads/Tracks  
Other  

Entrances

See main summary

Total Number of Breaks Through Ramparts:  
2:   Large sectors of the rampart are missing along the NNE side and at the WNW end

Number of Possible Original Entrances:  
2:   None

Guard Chambers:  

Chevaux de Frise:  

Entrances:
1. Simple Gap (South east):   None
2. Simple Gap (South west):   None

Enclosing Works

Single massively vitrified wall

Enclosed Area:
Area 1:   0.15ha.
Total:   0.15ha.

Total Footprint Area:  Noneha.

Ramparts

None

Multi-period Enclosure System:
✗   None

Ramparts Form a Continuous Circuit:
✗   None

Number of Ramparts:  
NE Quadrant:   0
SE Quadrant:   1
SW Quadrant:   1
NW Quadrant:   0
Total:   1

Morphology

Current Morphology:
Partial Univallate  
Univallate  
Partial Bivallate  
Bivallate  
Partial Multivallate  
Multivallate  
Unknown  

Detailed Morphology:
Partial Univallate  
Univallate  
Partial Bivallate  
Bivallate  
Partial Multivallate  
Multivallate  

Surface Evidence

Heavily vitrified wall

Enclosing Works (Surface):
None  
Earthen Bank  
Stone Wall  
Rubble  
Wall-walk  
Evidence of Timber  
Vitrification  
Other Burning  
Palisade  
Counter Scarp Bank  
Berm  
Unfinished  
Other  

Excavated Evidence

None

Enclosing Works (Excavation):
None  
Earthen Bank  
Stone Wall  
Murus Duplex  
Timber-framed  
Timber-laced  
Vitrification  
Other Burning  
Palisade  
Counter Scarp Bank  
Berm  
Unfinished  
No Known Excavation  
Other  

Other

Gang Working:
✗   None

Ditches:
✗   None

Number of Ditches:  None

Annex:
✓   The existence of an extensive outer enclosure (Harding, Ralston and Burgess 1995; Harding 1997, 121; 2004a, 141-4; 2004b) is disputed by RCAHMS, who could find no in situ vitrifaction in the outer walls and considered the pieces of vitrifaction they observed to be material incorporated into later agricultural enclosures associated with the extensive rig and furrow visible E of the fort (Geddes and Hale 2010, 23-4).

References

Anon (1780) 'Sketch of the ground and remains of a fort at Dunagoyle on the south west end of the island of Bute', held at the Bute Archive, Mount Stuart

Duffy, P R J (2012) One Island, Many Voices: Bute, Archaeology and the Discover Bute Landscape Partnership Scheme, Donington (pp 9,10,75,76,80,81)

Geddes and Hale, G F and A G C (2010) RCAHMS: The Archaeological Landscape of Bute, Edinburgh

Harding, D W (1997) 'Forts, duns, brochs and crannogs: Iron Age settlements in Argyll', in Ritchie, G The archaeology of Argyll, Edinburgh

Harding, D W (2004a) The Iron Age in Northern Britain: Celts and Romans, natives and invaders, Routledge: London & New York

Harding, D W (2004b) 'Dunagoil, Bute, re-instated', Transactions of the Buteshire Natural History Society 26 (2004), 1-19

Harding, Ralston and Burgess, D W, I and C (1995) 'Dunagoil, Isle of Bute (Kingarth parish), survey', Disc Exc Scot 1995, 65

Hewison, Rev. J K (1892-93) 'On the Prehistoric forts of the Island of Bute'. PSAS 27 (1893-3), 281-93

Mann, L M (1915) 'Report on the relics discovered during excavations in 1913 at cave at Dunagoil, Bute, and in 1914 at the fort at Dunagoil, Bute (with suggestions as to the probable history and chronology of the site)', Trans Buteshire Natur Hist Soc 8 (1915), 61-86

Mann, L M (1925) 'Note on the results of the exploration of the fort at Dunagoil'. Trans Buteshire Natur Hist Soc 9 (1925), 54-60

Marshall, J N (1915) 'Preliminary notes on some excavations at Dunagoil fort and cave'. Trans Buteshire Natur Hist Soc 8 (1915), 42-86

Nisbet, H C (1975) 'A geological approach to vitrified forts, part II: bedrock and building stone'. Sci & Archaeol 15 (1975), 11

Ross, W (1880) Blain's History of Bute, in Rev. William Ross Rothesay



Terms of Use

This work is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0 and should be cited as:

Lock, Gary and Ralston, Ian. 2024. Atlas of Hillforts of Britain and Ireland. Available at: https://hillforts.arch.ox.ac.uk


Document Version 1.1